Thursday, 17 May 2012

The Edge Debate on Shale

The Edge met at the Institution of Civil Engineers on 23rd April to ask Is Shale Gas a Game Changer?

This debate moved the discussion of shale beyond just the potential environmental effects of its adoption to the implications of shale gas becoming a major source of energy in the UK and globally. Chris Huhne chaired the event with John Miles of Arup, Mark Whitby of Davis Maquire + Whitby and Bill Bordass as speakers.

Huhne’s opening gambit introduced the idea that Fukushima has brought about a reduced interest in nuclear leaving a vacuum for a new and abundant energy source while in America, where shale gas has been energetically extracted, land rights mean that landowners are happy to exploit wealth locked in their land by selling the gas. The US has had an infamous lack of environmental controls on the shale extraction process as explored in the shocking film Gaslands and Methane is a dangerous by-product. Of course, closer to home, Quadrilla have been looking to extract new found shale in Lancashire. It is understood that shale is abundant in many regions of the world; enough for it to play a significant role in future energy production.

In the States, gas prices have halved over the last 3 years following high gas prices being linked to and possibly contributing to the economic crash. The suggestion arose that low energy prices facilitated by shale may stimulate economic recovery by attracting inward investment because low energy means low manufacture costs which means more manufacturing. China and South America have a great deal of shale, with the likelihood being that it’ll get used. Can the UK to be a leader for responsible extraction?

The UK cannot rely on other countries’ supplies of gas in future and the drive to a nuclear renaissance has been stopped in its tracks following Fukushima. This points to shale being a helpful energy source as long as it is affordable and the CO2 captured by CCS. Whitby explored how gas pricing in the UK/Europe where its link to oil prices differs to that in America where pricing is independent and open to offer/acceptance. Decoupling gas prices from oil prices through abundant shale would make shale cheap.

If shale was taken on internationally, there may be no significant exporters of gas any more, particularly if gas prices became unlinked to oil and decreased. This might in turn enable a switch from coal to gas which would on the surface see great CO2 emissions reductions. The belching elephant in the room here is methane, which with a global warming potential more than 20 times that of CO2 could see force a warming tipping point. International shale extraction must therefore be meticulously monitored, but, if done properly offers an energy source which in global warming terms is preferable to coal. CCS would be a crucial development to minimise the global warming impact of shale. Further, might shale gas be a natural, cheap partner to wind?

Should shale be broadly adopted leading to lower gas prices, might a sensible strategy be to force energy companies into fixing gas prices per unit as they stand and investing any profit into renewables? That way, shale could be seen to be a bridge towards a renewables-based energy portfolio.

Following broad debate about the economic, scientific, political and environmental aspects of shale, personal carbon allowances were mooted as a crucial intervention regardless of where we source our energy. The room was wary of a plentiful new fossil fuel which may distract the energy industry, public and governments from the need to switch to a carbon neutral lifestyle which underlined the simple need to reduce energy demand. How long until a political party can be elected with personal carbon allowances within their manifesto?

Thursday, 3 May 2012

Creative Continuity

'Void' is an installation by the artist, Aeneas Wilder, which completed construction today on the building site of our new studios in Islington. The site-specific project, sponsored by the contractors, Jerram Falkus, and co-curated by August Art and Kate Goodwin of the RA, will be supported by, and ultimately destroyed by, the building and is part of Cullinans' continuing collaboration with artists.

The building began life as a Victorian foundry and was converted into artist's studios in the early 1990s when Cullinans bought the building along with their current offices on Baldwin Terrace. 'Void' will be created in the building that is now undergoing extensive reconstruction, with a new steel frame to support the listed facade and roof trusses. Hovering above the ground and spanning almost seven metres, Wilder's work consists of hundreds of pieces of wood wedged between two of the columns. His previous installations have involved precariously balancing small pieces of wood to create free-standing, large scale, complex structures which he ceremoniously knocks down, in seconds, at the end of exhibitions. This time he will not destroy his work, but allow the installation to collapse of its own accord.

The installation, with builders working around it, will be projected via a live webcam into August Art's gallery space on Shoreditch High Street and will be visible from the street from 3rd May to 2nd June 2012. The gallery will also publish pictorial and text 'essays' exploring some of the forces, both physical and metaphysical, that create, threaten to destroy, and effectively are integral to the work.


Photos: Aeneas Wilder

'Void'
3rd May - 2nd June 2012
August Art Gallery: 224 Shoreditch High Street, London E1 6PJ
Open: Wed - Sat, 1 - 6pm
Location of installation: Baldwin Terrace, London N1 7RU (visible from street, but no access allowed into building)

Tuesday, 24 April 2012

Steps towards more sustainable specification



Last Thursday we hosted our spring sustainability talk. Graham Hilton, Gary Newman, and Brian Murphy of the Alliance for Sustainable Building Products (ASBP) gave the assembled crowd an engaging and fast paced presentation of the difficulties in specifying environmentally sound products.
As energy use in buildings falls (due to improved efficiencies of mechanical and electrical systems) the embodied energy of building materials becomes a more significant proportion of its carbon footprint. Part of the aim of the recently established ASBP is to tackle this issue and demystify what is a “green” product. Any visitor to Ecobuild will be aware that the vast majority of suppliers claim to be conscious of the impacts of their products. While many are likely to match their claims there is no standardised method of providing hard evidence. If a system such as Natureplus was in place, specifiers could consider this figure along with cost and aesthetics when choosing which brick, plasterboard, etc. to pick. Brian painted an image of manufactures fiercely competing to win gold in their product category.
There was interesting question and answer session afterwards, most memorable was the debate regarding the BRE’s Green Guide to Specification. It’s author Jane Anderson discussed it’s strengths and weakness, along with ways in which the ASBP’s work can address it’s shortcomings. Our guests left with an awareness of the urgent need for clarity in this critical carbon cutting area of construction.
Here at Cullinans we will be enthusiastically following the developments of the ASBP in the future.

Saturday, 21 April 2012

NHBC: two political events in a week

Lynne Sullivan http://www.sustainablebydesign.co.uk/ got the last question and Tim Yeo, Tory Chairman DECC Select Committee, grabbed it; Yeo agreed with her suggestion that we should reverse the tariff structure for electricity and charge those who use more at a higher rate rather than at a lower rate as now; then he went on to suggest that what we really needed was personal carbon allowances - hurrah!

So we finished on a high although I doubt that the Chancellor will be worried. This NHBC Foundation and APPG for Sustainable Housing debate at the House of Commons was well attended by senior NHBC people, housebuilders, contractors, manufacturers and some concerned architects. Elegantly chaired by Nick Raynsford ("this winter the only heating we needed in our new highly insulated flat was the towell rail for one hour in the morning and half an hour in the evening"), Hilary Benn and Tim Yeo discussed the need for More Homes and Greener Homes with support from David Smith, Sunday Times Economics Editor, and Zero Carbon Hub Director Neil Jefferson.

David Smith set the tone by declaring there would be no 'sudden thawing of the economy any time soon'. But what surprised me was the quiet but almost universal criticism of the Government's lack of understanding and general vacillation; this from a fairly conservative audience and Yeo did little to counter it.

Then yesterday the same people gathered at NHBC's office in the City at 8am to hear Boris Johnson on the hustings; we were joined by the specialist press and charities such as Crisis and Shelter so the wide-ranging and focussed critical questioning resulted in a mixture of pledges and evasion. Boris's face is a great ever-changing puzzle with those tiny eyes that narrow when he is thinking; he entertained us of course, enjoying sailing close to the wind eg. "That person known as the Jaws of Death...George Osborne."

More style than substance and on his own, without any heckling, I thought he was a bit lost and kept invoking Ken Livingstone for something to attack. Of course he took credit for all the activities that Ken had commissioned in the previous regime and defended his 'cleanest bus in Europe' but there were precious few ideas.

Lets hope NHBC can get Ken so we can see how he performs without a punchbag.

Thursday, 29 March 2012

National Heat Map

This week DECC and the Centre for Sustainable development released the National Heat Map. The mammoth task shows heat usage of buildings across England.




The user friendly map is a a helpful way to assess areas which would benefit from low carbon heat projects.

Thursday, 26 January 2012

Please don't scrap BREEAM Mr Gove!

It has been suggested that the Goverment is about to sign off the scrapping of BREEAM as a requirement for school design following Sebastian James' singling it out as part of 'the excessive burden of regulation'. While not being perfect, BREEAM has achieved some major changes to our industry and it seems reckless to chuck it out without reallocating the best bits into the Building Regs and Planning. UKGBC and the Aldersagate Group have written an excellent letter which was reported in Building's Breaking News on Tuesday
http://www.building.co.uk/5030948.article?origin=bldgbreakingnewsletter.

So yesterday I wrote to Secretary of State Gove on behalf of the former Zero Carbon Task Force:

"I write as the Chairman of the former Zero Carbon Schools Task Force (2009-10) to express my concern that you may be considering the dropping of the BREEAM metric. My understanding is that, far from being a major burden, the construction industry has responded pretty well to this challenge, as it usually does, and that BREEAM Excellent has delivered significant carbon savings at next to no cost (+ 0.7%).

The industry needs certainty of work flow and the progressive raising of standards to a timetable so that it can prepare and not waste money gearing up for a phantom. The overall task of saving 34% of UK emissions by 2030 en route for 80% reduction by 2050 is a difficult challenge and schools have a key role to play both in the actual reduction of emissions and in the behaviour change of tomorrow’s citizens, whose futures we can so easily jeopardise.

Few would defend the last letter of BREEAM and some of the items have passed or can readily and more properly pass into the Building Regulations and the Planning process; BRE could certainly feed back much more to the industry. The Department has a long tradition of research and learning from what has and has not been achieved in school design. So I hope I am mistaken in being led to understand that your Department is preventing Partnerships for Schools from publishing the excellent Post-Occupancy Evaluation work that they have done. At a time of major change as the industry strives to mitigate the effects of the changing climate, we desperately need this feedback in order to do for less and to build more resilient schools.

So please do not abandon BREEAM until there has been a full review of its impact and the key elements relocated, as is being done with the Code for Sustainable Homes at CLG. And on behalf of the Zero Carbon Task Force, I would be grateful if you could re-convene a meeting of the TF so we can explain to you and your officials how Energy and Carbon Savings can be made at little or no additional cost to prepare your estate for a more sustainable future."

Wednesday, 18 January 2012

Demolition or Refurbishment

On Monday evening Prof. Anne Power from LSE gave a thought provoking presentation at the Institute of Civil Engineers. She began by tackling the governments notion of a housing shortage in the UK. We currently have 25million homes (17million 3bed+). Also called into question was the idea that we reuse plastic bags but not a house!

She weighed up the argument for demolition or refurbishment in terms of
1. Economic cost
2. Environmental cost
3. Social Cost

She questioned some of common misconceptions in the refurbishment debate and spoke at length about the green deal.

For an hours watching well spent click on the link below for a recording of the lecture.