Showing posts with label The Edge. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Edge. Show all posts

Thursday, 8 May 2014

Edge Commission begins to get some definition

The Panel

The Commission



Last evening the Edge  held the third session of the Commission of Inquiry into Future Professionalism focussing on ‘Society’ with the President of the Landscape Institute, the Immediate Past Presidents of ICE and RTPI and Matthew Taylor, Chief Executive of the RSA and formerly Head of Tony Blair’s Policy Unit at No 10.    The Commission is sponsored by the Ove Arup Trust and is chaired by Paul Morrell, the first UK Government Chief Construction Adviser (2009-12); he is supported by


•    Isabel MacAllister, Director of Sustainability at Mace,
•    Barrister Jenny Baster, Arup,
•    Architect Karen Rogers, currently acting as a major client
•    QS Tony Burton, incoming Chairman of CIC and
•    Prof Alan Penn, Bartlett Dean (unable to attend this session)

We will need to wait for Denise Chevin’s write-up to be posted alongside the first two on the Edge website and for the final deliberations of the Commission, hopefully before the summer.   The over-riding concern of the Edge is how to promote inter-disciplinary behaviour and collaboration between the institutions.  They of course all have histories, some long and distinguished, and they have members who often disagree, making the development of policies difficult and shared policies more difficult.

This was brought to a head in a remarkably joined up and rapid response to the flooding in the Somerset Levels earlier this year.  Sue Illman led the response from the Landscape Institute with an open letter to David Cameron with support from 16 Institutions but sadly not including the RIBA or RTPI!  Her letter hit the magic spot of the first story on the Today programme and thus achieved wide coverage.  Matthew Taylor pointed out collaborative action is essential but speed is not always a virtue as Chris Smith demonstrated by choosing the precise moment as Chair of the Environment Agency to intervene and shut up the red-meat politicians calling for the abolition of his Agency.

Matthew described a three tier theoretical framework within which our Institutions operate:
•    Leadership/followship that can control or can convene opinions
•    Solidarity through membership that can be exclusive or inclusive
•    Individualism/enterprise that could promote creativity or commercialism

And much else besides – read Denise to find out more  including what to do about the surplus of architects and the shortage of engineers; my long-standing position has been to reduce the architecture training to four years (+ practice) the first of which is a cross-disciplinary Foundation Year, so that more of us end up in the right place.  Interestingly this hovered within the Farrell Review if not in the final Report.  The Chairman had the best quote of the evening “architects are the nurses of the construction industry; it doesn’t matter how badly you treat them, there will always be more waiting to become one!"

Tuesday, 19 November 2013

Happold Lecture Take 2

Friday saw Robin Nicholson reprise his CIC Ted Happold Medal Lecture for Cullinan Studio and guests during a wine and cheese evening at Cullinans' canal-side office. Speeding through the last 25 years of the construction industry, Robin's lecture hinged on his experience of various landmark construction industry reports, taskforces and forums.
 
Throughout the talk, a common theme picked out by Robin was an increasing change of bias evident in each report, shifting towards a focus on the client and end user. This goes hand-in-hand with the more socially-driven agenda that has emerged at the forefront of sustainable practice.
 
 
For Robin, the 1994 Latham Report ('Constructing the Team') signalled the first time members of the construction industry created a "public interest manifesto", rather than a self-serving industry report. Four years later, the "industry-shaking" Egan Report ('Rethinking Construction') championed the concept of demonstration projects in order to better assimilate lessons learnt throughout the construction process - another move in favour of client and user. As well as this, Robin described the Egan Report as a significant "early stumbling" into sustainability. How much these projects realistically impacted upon future good practice is up for debate, however they made clear the complexity of true change in the industry.


But Robin maintains the future should be bright. From the optimistic Paul Morrell notion that "design is free if there is a 10% building performance improvement", to the presence of think tanks such as EDGE which continue to debate industry progress and direction , to the smartening of practice through BIM, its clear that attitudes are evolving. Success and sustainability will lie in properly seeing concepts through in practice - in Robin's words "now we just need to do it!"



Further reading:

- The Carbon Tracker Initiative's report "Unburnable Carbon 2013" which few audience members had come across.

- Zero Carbon Britain 2013 report: Robin noted that the Zero Carbon Britain launch had a very poor representation from the construction industry.

- EDGE 2013 report
 
 

Thursday, 17 May 2012

The Edge Debate on Shale

The Edge met at the Institution of Civil Engineers on 23rd April to ask Is Shale Gas a Game Changer?

This debate moved the discussion of shale beyond just the potential environmental effects of its adoption to the implications of shale gas becoming a major source of energy in the UK and globally. Chris Huhne chaired the event with John Miles of Arup, Mark Whitby of Davis Maquire + Whitby and Bill Bordass as speakers.

Huhne’s opening gambit introduced the idea that Fukushima has brought about a reduced interest in nuclear leaving a vacuum for a new and abundant energy source while in America, where shale gas has been energetically extracted, land rights mean that landowners are happy to exploit wealth locked in their land by selling the gas. The US has had an infamous lack of environmental controls on the shale extraction process as explored in the shocking film Gaslands and Methane is a dangerous by-product. Of course, closer to home, Quadrilla have been looking to extract new found shale in Lancashire. It is understood that shale is abundant in many regions of the world; enough for it to play a significant role in future energy production.

In the States, gas prices have halved over the last 3 years following high gas prices being linked to and possibly contributing to the economic crash. The suggestion arose that low energy prices facilitated by shale may stimulate economic recovery by attracting inward investment because low energy means low manufacture costs which means more manufacturing. China and South America have a great deal of shale, with the likelihood being that it’ll get used. Can the UK to be a leader for responsible extraction?

The UK cannot rely on other countries’ supplies of gas in future and the drive to a nuclear renaissance has been stopped in its tracks following Fukushima. This points to shale being a helpful energy source as long as it is affordable and the CO2 captured by CCS. Whitby explored how gas pricing in the UK/Europe where its link to oil prices differs to that in America where pricing is independent and open to offer/acceptance. Decoupling gas prices from oil prices through abundant shale would make shale cheap.

If shale was taken on internationally, there may be no significant exporters of gas any more, particularly if gas prices became unlinked to oil and decreased. This might in turn enable a switch from coal to gas which would on the surface see great CO2 emissions reductions. The belching elephant in the room here is methane, which with a global warming potential more than 20 times that of CO2 could see force a warming tipping point. International shale extraction must therefore be meticulously monitored, but, if done properly offers an energy source which in global warming terms is preferable to coal. CCS would be a crucial development to minimise the global warming impact of shale. Further, might shale gas be a natural, cheap partner to wind?

Should shale be broadly adopted leading to lower gas prices, might a sensible strategy be to force energy companies into fixing gas prices per unit as they stand and investing any profit into renewables? That way, shale could be seen to be a bridge towards a renewables-based energy portfolio.

Following broad debate about the economic, scientific, political and environmental aspects of shale, personal carbon allowances were mooted as a crucial intervention regardless of where we source our energy. The room was wary of a plentiful new fossil fuel which may distract the energy industry, public and governments from the need to switch to a carbon neutral lifestyle which underlined the simple need to reduce energy demand. How long until a political party can be elected with personal carbon allowances within their manifesto?

Thursday, 5 November 2009

The Edge

Members of the Edge were out in force at the Institution of Civil Engineers (London) on Tuesday to hear the Presidential Address by fellow Edge Member Prof. Paul Jowitt. "Now is the time" is a powerful challenge to all civil engineers to provide sustainable infrastructure for everyone on the planet including the one billion who have none. The address is available on ice.org.uk/president. Edge members present included Adam Poole (Buro Happold), Paddy Conaghan (Hoare Lea), Michael Dickson (Buro Happold), Mike Murray (1to1solutions), Mark Whitby (co-founder Whitby Bird), Max Fordham (co-founder Max Fordham LLP), Jan Hellings (Olympic Development Authority), Chris Twinn (Arup) and our Robin Nicholson (ECA).