Monday, 15 April 2013

Allowable Solutions, Pennies from Heaven?


This month we were joined by James Blackburn of Carbon Green Consulting Ltd for a CPD seminar about Sustainable Development in relation to the new National Planning Policy Framework and upcoming changes to Part L of the Building Regs.  We were also joined by our friends from the Sustainable Development Foundation for what turned out to be a lively debate.

James’ engaging presentation explained the key driving principles behind the new policies relating to sustainability, and took us through the broader implications in relation to the government’s zero carbon agenda and housing development (the full presentation is available to download on the CGC website).

A memorable image from the talk was that of swooning ‘Ethel the planning officer’, in need of smelling salts following the shock induced by being presented with the NPPF – a document which claims to slash bureaucracy in Local Authorities by reducing over 1000 pages of policy to a document merely 80ish pages long.  But once over the excitement of reduced reading times, what exactly is on offer? 

The hot topic of the day turned out to be ‘Allowable Solutions’; a controversial carbon credits system which will allow housing developers to ‘top up’ their credit when target carbon reductions are too difficult to achieve.  This ‘topping up’ will manifest itself as a contribution through the Local Authority (not dissimilar to an S106 Agreement).   A myriad of ‘Possible Approved ‘ measures are currently offered up as acceptable forms of AS, including: ‘Green Deal, District Heating projects, Social Housing Retrofit, Renewable Energy, Embodied Carbon Initiatives, Low Carbon (LED) Lighting…’

Whilst it was generally acknowledged that the good intentions behind Allowable Solutions are a positive ‘step in the right direction’, they were generally met with suspicion.  Reactions during the discussion included: ‘Who will check that they have been carried out effectively and a resulting reduction in carbon has been achieved?’, ‘There are too many options, why isn’t there one clear programme that the money goes towards?’ and even, ‘Could the contractors pop round to the neighbours’ houses and offer to insulate their homes whilst they were at it?’… 

Pooling resources freed up by the scheme in order to build large-scale renewable infrastructures at regional or national level seems like a viable plan in terms of economies of scale, however, the apparently vague and multifaceted nature of AS in their current form doesn’t inspire confidence that this would be managed effectively. 

On taking a step back, there seems to be an obvious broken link in the cycle.  If a major factor behind the need for AS is the prohibitive cost of zero carbon building, why not use the money in the pot to subsidise carbon-cutting building products, therefore making them more appealing to home owners and housing developers?  As construction industry professionals, shouldn’t we be lobbying for a solution which would improve the quality of our building stock, rather than offsetting the problem elsewhere?

Affordable Solutions have the potential to accelerate carbon reduction, if these pennies from heaven are channelled in the right direction.  With some rapid re-thinking of the ‘Possible Approved’ measures, could AS help us hit zero carbon targets in 2016?  Food for thought.

Thursday, 11 April 2013

Libya Calling: RIBA Mission to Tripoli, 24-28 March 2013

“There is a moral imperative… that the institute should contribute what it can to the reconstruction of countries that British planes have bombed,” said Building Design magazine’s Ellis Woodman of the RIBA’s recent partnering mission to Tripoli (‘Libya’s aid is some reparation’ – BD Online 28.03.13). The reality is a country whose bombsites are few, peripheral and largely ex-governmental; surgically removed by NATO with only minor pockmarking to even the nearest bystander apartments. First-timers to Libya do also leap to the “British planes have bombed…” conclusion. In fact it is 42 years of neglect, corruption, underinvestment, political isolation and woeful or hands-off planning that have achieved what no ordnance could have: decrepit infrastructure, poor quality buildings, gridlocked roads, fly-tipped left-over spaces, the oppression of civic expression and a denial of the street as a civic space. Here, in the legacies of dictatorship, lies the RIBA’s mission.


There is a “moral imperative” to this work, even if Woodman is right that “some soft diplomacy is at work in this engagement… brokering relationships that will ultimately be of profit to the RIBA’s members.” “Moral,” because as Architects, we have a duty to work for the betterment of the built environment, wherever the society that it serves. “Imperative,” because with a projected 20% growth in GDP this year alone (IMF), the world’s fifth largest oil reserves (now almost back to pre-war exports) but with only a caretaker government and still no agreed constitution, the built environment is more vulnerable than ever.
 
It is vulnerable because problems that were manifest during my time in Libya between 2009 and 2011 – money, land, cars and housing –have become yet more urgent. It has a money problem – too much of it but not enough experience to spend it wisely. It has a land problem – a population of 6m, mostly stretched across its 2000km long coastline (often without title) where sprawl, the protection of sites of national importance or the making of good streets and civic spaces is managed only by dated planning models, if at all. It has a car problem – streets choked to gridlock by an oil subsidy that still makes it cheaper to fill up with petrol than with water, stoked by a booming import market for hand-me-down EU cars at bargain prices. Chronic housing shortages persist, exacerbated by a young population that prefers to move out of the family home. Elhabib Alamin, the Minister for Culture and Civil Society, is all too aware of the problems and the coming explosion of infrastructure investment: “We have one year to design the software before the hardware starts to arrive.” For the relative newcomers to governance that we met and in the context of an international perception of volatility that discourages travel and collaboration, our RIBA mission was significant.
 
As investors look on, Libya’s Architects are stuck on the side lines. Their title is not recognised as distinct from Engineers and there was, until recently, no voice for the profession. Meanwhile, Architects suffer from the perception shared by Libya’s Urban Planning Authority (UPA), that “Architects do not offer spatial or planning ideas.” Indeed, despite the valiant leadership of Osama Abdul Hadi – head of Tripoli School of Architecture whom we met there on graduation day – a lack of engagement from the international architecture community has visibly distanced his students from the level of contextual, social, cultural, climatic and sustainability debate that guides good architecture elsewhere.
We are supporting a lecture series and teaching initiative from visiting Architects to energise schools with new ideas. Meanwhile, in the industry, it is hoped that new laws to guarantee knowledge exchange through collaboration with Libyan counterparts will undo the trend towards “suitcase architecture” that once dominated the pre-revolution outsourcing of Libya’s major projects. Cullinans’ on-going relationship with Sami Jaouda’s Libyan Engineering Office (himself a delegate to the RIBA mission) on the substantial Madinat Hadaek Shahat project was and is a rare exception of a collaborative project.

 
 
Something haschanged though. The cultural amnesia brought by Gadaffi’s quasi-socialist autocracy has left a longing for Libyan identity in its wake. After decades of Italian Occupation and post-war, Anglo-French military administration, preceded by centuries of colonisation by Phoenicians, Greeks, Romans, Byzantines and Ottomans, Libyan identity remains nebulous. Here again, we found Architects being turned to as part of the solution by The Minister for Culture (an archaeologist by training), the director of Libya’s Ancient Towns Administration and by the inspiring Ikram Bash Imam – Minister for Tourism and Libya’s first female Architect. “How will archaeologists ever know that here was Libya?” we were asked. With a professional and political class that is often Western-trained or until-recently exiled, Libyans will need to look more broadly to find their cultural identity.

It was the embryonic, Benghazi-based, Libyan Institute of Architects (LIA) who first approached the RIBA in 2012, leading to UKTI (UK Trade & Industry) backing for our March 2013 mission that included five RIBA representatives plus two of us with past working experience of the country. The LIA brought with them their Tripolitanian colleagues, the Libyan Board of Architecture (LBA) and, together, our joint Libyan-UK mission helped to extend a network that ranges from conservation (the Historic Towns Authority) to renewable technologies (the Renewable Energy Authority of Libya, REAOL).
 
With a supporting resource in the RIBA, these often young and UK-US-trained Architects plan to become the voice of their marginalised profession. Ministerial offers to sit on decision-making committees and invitations from the Planning and Housing authorities to take part in collaborative workshops make the prospect of an effective lobby group for better procedure, regulation, strategy and design review more than possible.
“Think of Libya as a drug addict,” a director of the Libyan Investment and Development Company (LIDCO) told us. “Like a clinic, Libyan Architects must organise themselves and be ready when the country turns to them for answers.”

Posted by Philip Graham who worked alongside Cullinan Studio’s Roddy Langmuir on heritage, housing and urban projects in Libya from 2009-2011.

#RIBAlibya

Tuesday, 26 March 2013

The physiognomy of buildings

Another point that Victoria  Haines' made in her Ecobuild presentation on research for CALEBRE on user barriers to retrofit has been rattling around in my mind. This was the observation that windows are particularly cherished as features that define the character of their homes. When people are considering improvements they are often concerned about the impact that alterations to windows will have on the character of their homes and are reluctant to change them, often knowing more about them than 'the experts'.


Is this just sentiment or an indication of something deeper? The observation highlighted an issue that has been intriguing me for a little while - the emotional connection between people and the appearance of a building. Not so much the building as a whole, but specifically the composition of the facade. Our former partner Jonathan Hale's probings on the relationship between architecture and the body suggest this area is under researched. We are used to thinking about this in aesthetic or performance rather than psychological terms.

There's been a lot in the news recently about the autism spectrum and Asperger's syndrome - even the recent dramatisation of the novel 'The curious incident of the dog in the night-time' drawing attention to it.  Sufferers have difficulties developing empathetic relationships with other people and have  impaired non-verbal behaviour such as poor eye contact or a total inability to read facial expressions.  

Whilst physiognomy - the practice of assessing a person's character by interpretation of their face - might be seen as pseudoscience, an appreciation of the importance of understanding body language or 'kinesics' in communication, leadership and successful group work has become mainstream. We make constant conscious and subconscious readings and judgements about people's character and mood by their appearance and gestures which we do well to recognise. 

I think there is a useful parallel with buildings, and that reading the facade in anthropomorphic terms can help develop a richer narrative about it - a new physiognomy of buildings.  As well as analysing a facade in functional and cultural terms, we should listen more closely to our emotional response. 

By ignoring or seeing as irrelevant the potential for this reading, we are in danger of suffering from a kind of Asperger's syndrome of architecture.

People often talk of windows as being the eyes of a building. Knowing how important eyes are to communication between people, it would not be surprising if windows added more to its character than other elements of the architectural composition.  As we demand more of our building envelopes to improve thermal comfort and control energy flows, we must not lose sight of those emotional responses that make us comfortable in our environment.  The CALEBRE research suggests the great retrofit mission might founder unless these too are recognised.

Sunday, 10 March 2013

Customer Appealing retrofit

Ecobuild this year was as overwhelming in ideas as in products with its excellent seminar series. In the 'Refurbishing Britain' theme, lessons from CALEBRE focused mainly on technical solutions. But as the CA in CALEBRE stands for 'Customer Appealing', Victoria Haines summary of findings on people's appetite for improving their homes was particularly interesting.

After all, if we could get our teenagers to turn down their heating and turn off their lights we would probably be closer to the 80% reduction needed than replacing our boilers with heat pumps.

This is in the wider context that energy efficiency as such is a low priority for most people: comfort yes, cost of fuel yes but reducing carbon emissions no. The evidence suggests that unless there is a simultaneous change in behaviour and attitude, homes refurbished as part of the Green Deal or otherwise will be more comfortable but not reduce emissions.

Barriers to retrofit include the comfortable relationship people have with their homes, particularly older 'hard to treat' properties.  Her evidence shows that most people make the major changes to their homes when they first move in, with a readiness to live with disruption then that they would not tolerate 20 years later.

With the scale of the refurbishment challenge needed we have focused on physical solutions - still with many questions over their effectiveness. Clearly they are important but are only a part of a more nuanced approach needed. 'Hard to treat' solid wall properties are a huge challenge to meeting our emissions reduction targets. Linking a reduction of Stamp Duty to undertaking major Green Deal work would be a neat way of both incentivising energy-saving refurbishment at a point that most suits people, as well as stimulating the housing market.

In the meantime, the bigger question remains - how do we change our behaviours to live within our means?


Monday, 4 March 2013

Garden Cities - about flowers or land?

The latest Housebuilder magazine carries an article on the renewed interest in Garden Cities: 'The government want the industry to rediscover the joy of garden cities to help boost housing supply and create sustainable development'.  Nick Clegg, following the Coalition's line, says 'Garden Cities should be built across the heart of middle England'.

You can't help feeling that this interest comes from the appeal of the appearance of the Garden Cities, with the hope that Nimbyism will be less vigorous if 'high quality housing' is built.

Re-reading Howard's 'Garden Cities of Tomorrow' what is fascinating is that the physical vision can almost be condensed into Howard's short quote from Ruskin: '... clean and busy street within and the open country without, with a belt of beautiful garden and orchard around the walls, so that from any part of the city perfectly fresh aire and grass and sight of the horizon might be reachable in a few minutes walk'. But the essence of the ideas are not primarily about the city's physical appearance - certainly not its flowers - but how a new financial model could capture land value for the benefit of the community. In fact the bulk of the book is about the financial arrangements to make this work.

With our current crisis of housing with supply both inadequate and unaffordable, particularly for young people, this revolution in how land value is captured is arguably more pressing than it has ever been. We have have to get beyond the present system whereby land at low value is acquired by private companies to feed into the market at just the right rate to maximise profits for their shareholders, which bears no relation to real needs of the population.

Groups such as the  Community Land Trust movement are doing work to counteract the prevailing model. Interestingly, they are often local and small scale and the idea can work at any scale - they are certainly not imposed top-down to cover middle England. Letchworth and Welwyn Garden Cities were of course initiated as local enterprises.

Those who understand the economics of this model (such as Fred Harrsion who predicted our current crash and ensuing recession in 2005), argue that a complete overhaul of taxation system is needed, with a tax on the 'rents of land' replacing income and corporation tax altogether.

But that's another story ...

Thursday, 21 February 2013

Healthy Retrofit

A good event on 'Healthy Retrofit' at Cullinan Studio's newly refurbished Foundry building on Wednesday last week, with retrofit challenges and achievements covered by Johnny Winter of Cullinan Studio, Neil May from ASBP and Richard Griffiths of Parity Projects.

The 'Healthy Retrofit' talk was hosted by Cullinan Studio in their new BREEAM 'Excellent' retofit offices.

Brendan Sexton of Cullinan Studio introducing the evening and our latest annual sustainability report.

Johnny Winter of Cullinan Studio began the evening with a talk on the retrofit of 
our Baldwin Terrace studios, including some of the lessons learnt from the process.

Neil May's talk on (a seemingly dry subject) -  'How sustainable products can assist with moisture control in retrofit' - was particularly timely.

Neil May of ASBP.

29% of UK housing stock is solid wall construction. As a nation we have to upgrade it successfully if we are to reduce our carbon emissions and provide comfortable homes that people can afford to heat.

Under the Green Deal, this widespread form of construction is labelled 'hard to treat'.

It's an odd situation to be in. At last, and for all the Green Deal's faults, something is being done to tackle the challenge of widescale retrofit of our existing housing. Now there is a growing pressure to get this work underway. But do we actually have the technical solutions?

The general 'golden rule' for the Green Deal is that the cost of carrying out improvement works is matched by savings in fuel bills. 'Hard to treat' properties can't meet this rule: the cost of insulating solid wall properties far exceeds the savings in fuel bills. To get this work done, additional subsidy is needed. This comes from the utility companies' 'Energy Company Obligation'. This subsidy is not given away but is paid for by a general increase in all our fuel bills. The utility companies are obliged to meet set carbon reduction targets, hence the pressure to get this work underway and fast.

Building Magazine on 8th February reported Encraft's recent study, which showed that the costs of the upgrading 'hard to treat' homes has been woefully underestimated.The effective cost per ton of carbon saved they estimate to be £180 compared with the government's £80, a difference we will all have to bear through increases to our fuel bills.

So it is more than ever important that the technical solutions employed do actually work.

Neil's overriding point was that we do not yet have robust, widely applicable, whole building solutions based on sound science: inappropriate and partial solutions seriously risk causing a new generation of moisture-related problems, from mould growth and ill-health, to fabric degradation and premature decay.

To meet this challenge we need the pace of research and dissemination to accelerate.

In the meantime, we need some good rules of thumb to guide us. In this debate the five 'principles for building' still stand up*. What are they? Two overriding constraints, two overarching objectives, and the fifth a guiding caution.

  • 'High to low' restates what should be obvious, that gravity generally makes water flow downhill, that temperature goes from hot to cold, that vapour diffuses from high to low vapour pressure.
  • 'Separate lives' reminds us that buildings are assembled in a process and that different materials move and decay at different rates, processes which if ignored cause premature failure.
  • 'Continuity' of performance is an implicit objective for the building envelope. The increased performance we now expect from our building envelopes, where internal conditions are held further apart from the external environment, means design has to be more rigorous to achieve this. Continuity of the measures to achieve continuity of performance has become more critical, whether at the air tightness line or thermal insulation. This might be obvious but it is only the Passivhaus standard that appears to recognise that continuity (by truly avoiding cold bridges and demanding a demonstrable air tightness performance) is an essential rather than a nice-to-have. By its nature, 'continuity' is often in conflict with 'separate lives'.
  • 'Balance' is the objective that encompasses the equilibrium of environmental conditions, of structural forces, and distribution of resources. Achieving balance is often in conflict with the constraint of 'high to low'.
  • The fifth, cautionary principle can be called 'creative pessimism' - accepting that in the world of building what can go wrong at some point will, and creatively anticipating it. I enjoyed Neil's restating this as the 'principle of forgiveness'.
The relevance of all this is that accepting and working with these principles by following some rules of thumb - 'going with the flow' - rather than fighting them against does reduce the risk of failure. Increasing thermal resistance towards the cold side and increasing vapour resistance towards the moist side is one such rule. External wall insulation still needs to be continuous but is inherently less risky than internal linings. Fighting against the principles always requires more highly stressed solutions, such as 100% vapour barriers. That is why we should all be concerned about the prospect of 'hard to treat' homes being internally lined with insulation.

Colin Rice, Cullinan Studio

*Addleson and Rice, Performance of Materials in Buildings, 1991

 Richard Griffiths from Parity Projects.

Q&A session following the three presentations.

The 'Healthy Retrofit' talk was presented by ASBP (Alliance for Sustainable Building Products) which is a cross sector, not for profit organisation, comprising building product manufacturers and distributors, specifiers, designers, architects, contractors, public interest and sustainability organisations, academics and other building practitioners.

The ASBP are committed to accelerating the transition to a high performance, healthy and low carbon built environment by championing the increased understanding and use of building products that meet demonstrably high standards of sustainability.

Wednesday, 2 January 2013

Rio Housing workshop


Last winter I found myself with 3 other London architects 'exporting' different aspects of UK design in the depths of the Belgrade snow.  This year I was one of six dropped by the British Embassy into a 2-day workshop in the humid warmth of Rio de Janiero. Both times I had the opportunity to discuss UK attitudes to sustainability as an essential part of good/great design.


Before he stood down, President Lula launched a programme, Minha Casa Minha Vida (My House My Life), to begin to address the massive popular housing shortage across Brazil http://www1.caixa.gov.br/gov/gov_social/municipal/programas_habitaca.  Having built 1 million homes last year and just as importantly having created 1.4m jobs, the Brazilian Ministry of Cities has much to be proud of as they move into the second wave of 1.4m homes.  But some questions were beginning to be asked about the long term impact of the programme; were the same mistakes being made in the drive for numbers as we have all made in the past. 


The workshop was a really brave initiative by Government inviting their critics from the academic world to review this programme and we were there to give some wider perspective.  We probably didn’t tell them much that they didn’t already know but by the end of the second day there was a general agreement about what might make a difference; on reflection such openness would be unthinkable in Whitehall. 


Following a meeting in November with the energetic programme leader Junia Santa Rosa at the AA, coordinated by Jorge Fiori, it seemed that we did have real expertise in areas that might be both new and helpful, especially Design Review.  So I was asked to make a presentation in the introductory session about the benefits offered by Design Council CABE Design Review, Building for Life 12 http://www.designcouncil.org.uk/Documents/Documents/OurWork/CABE/Building%20for%20Life/Building%20for%20Life%2012.pdf and the Cambridgeshire Quality Panel http://www.cambridgeshirehorizons.co.uk/qualitypanel/; I chair the latter with John Worthington and we review large housing schemes as (long-standing) critical friends under the four Cs - Community, Connectivity, Climate and Character.


Gilles Alvarenga of ZEDfactory and I spend two half-day sessions in the sustainability and technology group chaired by Junia Santa Rosa.  Our conclusions were not dissimilar from those of the other two groups in wanting better social and physical connectivity with the existing communities, proper social infrastructure, schools, health centres etc and accountable masterplanning.


But the strongest area of concern was the lack of significant regional variation in response to the varying climates and cultures; we proposed that there should be a series of smaller pilot projects to demonstrate regional needs and responses. Further we argued that all the schemes needed to be audited using a transparent tool like Building for Life to provide feedback and learning.


Overall we challenged them to think about the legacy of the programme; while recognising that 'you cannot change the tyre while riding the bicycle' as one delegate put it, there really is a need for the programme to evolve into My House My Life My City.  Discussions are now under way to see how we can develop the relationships established with the continuing support of the British Embassy.